[Gotham Dark Knight]

For a team with a short history, the Seattle Mariners have plenty of players to pick from....Griffey Jr., A-Rod, The Big Unit, and Ichiro to name a few.

[Lefty Noob]

And don't forget Edgar Martinez, Jay Buhner and Alvin Davis - all three members of the team's Hall of Fame. Hard to give a vote to a guy who played a decent portion of his career elsewhere, but I've got to go with Junior Griffey here. His best years were all as a Mariner.

[simple simon]

im going with the Unit ........... he is on of the great left handers there has been

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Lefty Noob

And don't forget Edgar Martinez, Jay Buhner and Alvin Davis - all three members of the team's Hall of Fame. Hard to give a vote to a guy who played a decent portion of his career elsewhere, but I've got to go with Junior Griffey here. His best years were all as a Mariner.

Al Davis...a blast from the past...but if you are going to mention him, I will add same era kin Mark Langston...

[Lefty Noob]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

Al Davis...a blast from the past...but if you are going to mention him, I will add same era kin Mark Langston...

I liked Langston. But alas, the team hasn't put him in their Hall of Fame. I wonder why not?

[simple simon]

you two crack me up ....... you know when i have made my choice there is no more room for discussion ............ and yet you continue to discuss

[Lefty Noob]

Originally Posted by simple simon

im going with the Unit ........... he is on of the great left handers there has been

You know only 1 of his 5 Cy Youngs came as a Mariner, right? Not to mention just 5/10 All-Star appearances and 1/3 20-win seasons?

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Lefty Noob

You know only 1 of his 5 Cy Youngs came as a Mariner, right? Not to mention just 5/10 All-Star appearances and 1/3 20-win seasons?

...mean while Junior had his best years there...

[legend]

Since three of their best have all played considerable time elsewhere, you have to go by what they did while there. That is easily Griffey. Next is A-Rod and then I think you have to go with Edgar over Randy Johnson.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by legend

Since three of their best have all played considerable time elsewhere, you have to go by what they did while there. That is easily Griffey. Next is A-Rod and then I think you have to go with Edgar over Randy Johnson.

I am not sold on Edgar (good hitter but no field) over the Big Unit.

[azrael492]

For me, this is another easy one. Griffey Jr. He came in as a teenager and gave them 10 spectacular years.

[vincesanity82]

Ken Griffey Jr. made the mariners...