[Bette]

As a result of one of coach Nolan's brainstorms, a medley of classical tunes from NFL films blared across camp. Coach Nolan figures players must learn to persevere through loud noise on Sundays. Apparently it didnt have a calming affect on TE Vernon Davis who ripped off LB Parys Haralson's helmet during a fight.
But at the center, were Alex Smith and Shaun Hill taking snaps in a competition that will likely last for three months.


Smith, Hill begin QB competition at center of 49ers' camp - International Herald Tribune


Just starting so the playing field is still level yet.

[azrael492]

I say if Smith is healthy he gets the job. He was considered an up and coming QB until the injury last season. They give him another shot.

[ninerfan1indahouse]

Originally Posted by azrael492

I say if Smith is healthy he gets the job. He was considered an up and coming QB until the injury last season. They give him another shot.

I never saw that out of Smith sure he had one year he went 16TD16INT still never posted over a 100% paser rating are 300 yard game but now with Hill on his heels maybe just maybe it will light a fire in him but my hopes are on Hill,thanks for the post Bette.

[Bette]

Originally Posted by azrael492

I say if Smith is healthy he gets the job. He was considered an up and coming QB until the injury last season. They give him another shot.

Originally Posted by ninerfan1indahouse

I never saw that out of Smith sure he had one year he went 16TD16INT still never posted over a 100% paser rating are 300 yard game but now with Hill on his heels maybe just maybe it will light a fire in him but my hopes are on Hill,thanks for the post Bette.

the year above you quoted was his first year as a starter. He seems to be a little heavy on the interceptions, but he's still a young quarterback. In his rookie year he had 1 td and 11 interceptions. In 07 in 7 games he had 2 TD and 4 int. Actually I thought he was better than that until I looked at the numbers. So if he doesnt get that fire lit in him this year, it definitely wont be his job. Its not his job to lose, its his job to win..

[Dusty]

If I were a Niner fan i'd want Shaun Hill as the quarterback. At least he's tough and with an improved line and Frank Gore at 100% I would take him as fantasy football backup anyday. Leave Alex Smith as a bust and a backup. Maybe some other team will want him

[ninerfan1indahouse]

This is one fan that would love to see Hill start.

[ninerfan1indahouse]

Originally Posted by Bette

the year above you quoted was his first year as a starter. He seems to be a little heavy on the interceptions, but he's still a young quarterback. In his rookie year he had 1 td and 11 interceptions. In 07 in 7 games he had 2 TD and 4 int. Actually I thought he was better than that until I looked at the numbers. So if he doesnt get that fire lit in him this year, it definitely wont be his job. Its not his job to lose, job to winits his ..

Numbers don't lie,love the quote,his job to win.....it's not his no longer

[Dusty]

Great move to make these two quarterbacks show what they got and then make a choice. I just think this is the last chance for Alex Smith to prove he can be successful. I also think think that Shaun Hill is a solid quarterback and will win the job easily.

[ninerfan1indahouse]

Originally Posted by Dusty

Great move to make these two quarterbacks show what they got and then make a choice. I just think this is the last chance for Alex Smith to prove he can be successful. I also think think that Shaun Hill is a solid quarterback and will win the job easily.

I think you hit the nail right on the head

[Dusty]

Definitely. I love it that Nolan is tossing out who was drafted when and who makes such and such amount of money and making Smith and Hill compete to see who can help the Niners be a better team.

[Seaking]

as long as the geniuses in the front office have smith at the helm the franchise will be held hostage i love it another easy confrence championship for the hawks

[ninerfan1indahouse]

Originally Posted by Seaking

as long as the geniuses in the front office have smith at the helm the franchise will be held hostage i love it another easy confrence championship for the hawks

We'll see about that my good man

[Bette]

I dont remember but wasnt Shaun Hill in the league a few years already?

[ninerfan1indahouse]

Originally Posted by Bette

I dont remember but wasnt Shaun Hill in the league a few years already?

6yrs never started a game,started 2 games 4 us and won both

[Bette]

Originally Posted by ninerfan1indahouse

6yrs never started a game,started 2 games 4 us and won both

And fans are basing their choice for Hill on that???