[simple simon]

the Philadelphia Eagles have a long list of players in the Hall Of Fame ...... but which of them is the greatest of all ?

Reggie White .... Chuck Bednarik .... Sonny Jurgensen ....... Harold Carmichael .... Mike Golic ...... or someone else ?

[simple simon]

it has to be Bednarik ........ he was the NFL's last full time two way player, and one of the toughest players ever

[njpsufan]

Hard to define... you forgot Steve Van Buren. I would divide it pre-1965 and after 1965. After '65 I say Bill Bergey or maybe Wilbert Montgomery.

[simple simon]

there are for sure people i leave off the list for each of these teams ...... just no need for all of them ........ and the true fans (such as yourself) will pull the best names out of the hat whether i list them or not

[Lefty Noob]

Buddy Ryan! Ha ha ha!

Actually, I'll have to ponder this one over, but my gut says to go with either Reggie or Carmichael.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by njpsufan

Hard to define... you forgot Steve Van Buren. I would divide it pre-1965 and after 1965. After '65 I say Bill Bergey or maybe Wilbert Montgomery.

I was gonna go with Chuck Bednarik ...but I think I am going with Van Buren on this one...no disrespect to Reggie White...(oh and TO for Honorable mention... )

[greengreenie]

Bednarik in the "classic era"; White in the "modern era". Bednarik gets the overall nod though. He just seems like the perfect Philly type player.