[Gotham Dark Knight]

I am starting a new type of thread calld Apples and Oranges, in which you get to pick the best player across two different sports..cause lets face it, th horse called A-Rod vs Pujols has been "written" into the ground…So, who was the better player Archie Manning or Ken Griffey Sr?...

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Heck...okay, I will kick this off myself...I am taking Archie...mister MVP for the Aints...Griffey was good, but he had Rose, Bench, Perez, Morgan and the Rest of the Machine to prop him up...Archie was Staubach's equal minus the Cowboys...and...and he has two superstar kids to Griffey's one...

[legend]

Archie Manning's accomplishments, which were few, are enhanced by the passage of time. Griffey played and contributed to championships.

Manning 125 TDs 173 interceptions
Griffey, Sr. .296 career average 200 stolen bases 2 World Series
I'll take Griffey

Good concept by the way, lots of fun

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by legend

Archie Manning's accomplishments, which were few, are enhanced by the passage of time. Griffey played and contributed to championships.

Manning 125 TDs 173 interceptions
Griffey, Sr. .296 career average 200 stolen bases 2 World Series
I'll take Griffey

Good concept by the way, lots of fun

Aaaaahhh...you are killing me Legends!...Manning was the Team!...a one man party in search of the right crowd...Kenny boy was not even the best player on the team...

[wedge]

But the real question is who produced a better offspring...Peyton Manning vs Ken Griffey Jr...that's a tough one.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by wedge

But the real question is who produced a better offspring...Peyton Manning vs Ken Griffey Jr...that's a tough one.

Wedge!...Come to join the party my good man...yes...well...Archie has two...so...he has a better shot...and Griffey Jr. has had all those injuries and is a bit disgruntle...so like I am saying ...its Archie all the way...