[Lefty Noob]

Yahoo! Sports has an interesting article talking about Notre Dame basketball coach Mike Brey and Fighting Irish football coach Charlie Weis.

Brey, Weis earn admissions’ trust - NCAA Football - Yahoo! Sports

It discusses some of their similarities and differences, and it got me wondering...
Which of the two coaches do you think is better than what they do? Which one is the better Notre Dame coach, Weis or Brey?

[vincesanity82]

Originally Posted by Lefty Noob

Yahoo! Sports has an interesting article talking about Notre Dame basketball coach Mike Brey and Fighting Irish football coach Charlie Weis.

Brey, Weis earn admissions’ trust - NCAA Football - Yahoo! Sports

It discusses some of their similarities and differences, and it got me wondering...
Which of the two coaches do you think is better than what they do? Which one is the better Notre Dame coach, Weis or Brey?

Even though ND has sucked past seasons, I think weis is still a good coach, just hasnt had much talent to work with..

[Lefty Noob]

Brey's no slouch himself, though. I think he's done more with less than what Weis had. Heck, Notre Dame's football team's been at or near the top of recruiting since he's been there. He got a great QB talent in Jimmy Claussen. Yeah, maybe you don't expect the freshman to set the world on fire, but with the QB carosel and going 3-9 while losing to some teams Notre Dame has no business losing too, it's hard NOT to give Brey the edge.

[D1recruiter]

Is this one of those Apples vs Oranges questions?