[bears9]

Who is the Best Player on the Yankees roster A-Rod Derek Jeter Marineno Rivera Hediki Matsui or someone else

[simple simon]

easily A-Rod ........ Jeter isnt even the best short stop on his own team

[Lefty Noob]

Rodriguez, for sure. Arguably the best player in baseball. On his own team, there's no argument.

[EmpireWF]

No argument here, A-Rod is deifnitely the best in the game.

Now if this was say...1998, Mariano or Jeter could run away with this.

[bears9]

A-ROd is the best in baseball and the Yankees

[LSC9901]

Rivera is a trick answer ... right ???

[vincesanity82]

A-Rod most def..

[legend]

Ask me who I want up in the postseason with the game on the line and I will say Jeter every time until A-Rod proves me wrong.

[ThePundit]

What? No Kei Igawa on the list. He got is ERA under 7 yesterday.

Matsui shouldn't be mentioned in the same breath as these other 3 guys.

[MVB]

A-Rod is the best player in baseball, so this is an easy question.

A better question would be: who is the second best player on the Yankee roster? Jeter or Rivera?

[Gotham Dark Knight]

WOW...A-Rod in a landslide...I thought you guys hated Mr. October-lite...