[simple simon]

there aren't many more storied franchises then the NY Giants ..... but who has been the greatest New York Giant of all time ?

Phil Simms ....... Lawrence Taylor ...... the Mara family ..... Frank Gifford ..... Harry Carson ........ Ray Flaherty ..... or someone else ?

[LSC9901]

Tiki Barber. Greatest running back ever ... or is he ???

[vincesanity82]

kerry collins..j/k

[simple simon]

ill be honest for me it is a tough choice between LT and the Mara's ........ of course LT is the man ... but the Mara's have done so much for the franchise and the NFL

[EmpireWF]

Lawrence Taylor...no question about it.

Of course Mr. Mara is probably just as important but man was LT so dominant or what?

[Lefty Noob]

The obvious choice is LT, but we can't forget some of the greats of the past - Emlen Tunnell and Mel Hein. You've got Gifford, Tittle and Huff. I was always a huge Harry Carson fan as well, and Mark Bavaro is one of the greatest tight ends to ever play the game. I guess I'll have to begrudgingly go with Taylor, though. Legendary linebacker, but I don't like the guy and I'd love to be able to say someone else deserves it more.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Title and Huff are my picks...then LT...

(Larry Csonka anyone... )

[azrael492]

LT. No choice.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by azrael492

LT. No choice.

Huff over the one dimensional LT

[azrael492]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

Title and Huff are my picks...then LT...

(Larry Csonka anyone... )

I think of Csonka as a dolphin more that a giant.