[vincesanity82]

He showed he could be rattled last night being sacked 5x and threw the ball everywhere but recievers at times. I remember one specific play where moss was wide open in the end zone and he threw the ball way over his head. Is he still considered NFL's Best?

[Lefty Noob]

He wasn't NFL best coming into yesterday (Peyton Manning), but I really don't think he hurt himself too bad with yesterday's performance. Regardless of what anyone thinks, it really was because the Giants had a great defensive gameplan and talented d-linemen who executed flawlessly. No quarterback could've withstood what New York threw at the Pats last night.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Lefty Noob

He wasn't NFL best coming into yesterday (Peyton Manning), but I really don't think he hurt himself too bad with yesterday's performance. Regardless of what anyone thinks, it really was because the Giants had a great defensive gameplan and talented d-linemen who executed flawlessly. No quarterback could've withstood what New York threw at the Pats last night.

Ditto...Peyton over Brady any day...and twice against the Giants...

[Seahawker 562]

if you mean tom petty, no.

[LSC9901]

Statistically yes he is the best of the current crop of QB's. Whether or not you like ratings is another story but it is all rated on performance ... not personalities. Brady has a 117.2 rating while Eli is a thrashing 73.9.

I will most certainly agree that the Giant's d line was tremendous last night. Just imagine where they would have been had they played that way every game. They may have had a 19-0 season.

[Quality88]

Originally Posted by LSC9901

Statistically yes he is the best of the current crop of QB's. Whether or not you like ratings is another story but it is all rated on performance ... not personalities. Brady has a 117.2 rating while Eli is a thrashing 73.9.

I will most certainly agree that the Giant's d line was tremendous last night. Just imagine where they would have been had they played that way every game. They may have had a 19-0 season.

What's Peyotn's ratin... as hee is the one they referred to and not Eli is this instance

[Quality88]

Originally Posted by Seahawker 562

if you mean tom petty, no.

Get over it.... the people you wanted to play didn't.... wait til next year and maybe you will get to see them

[LSC9901]

Originally Posted by Quality88

What's Peyotn's ratin... as hee is the one they referred to and not Eli is this instance

An even 98.0. Romo is 97.4, Favre is 95.7 (not bad for an old man) and McNabb is 89.9

[Quality88]

Originally Posted by LSC9901

An even 98.0. Romo is 97.4, Favre is 95.7 (not bad for an old man) and McNabb is 89.9

Ok.... you may proceed than sir

[Seahawker 562]

Originally Posted by Quality88

Get over it.... the people you wanted to play didn't.... wait til next year and maybe you will get to see them

I cant, it was just to horrible

[Quality88]

Originally Posted by Seahawker 562

I cant, it was just to horrible

For you maybe... Petty put on a good show. He wasn't at his best obviously, but it was still good.

[Seahawker 562]

Originally Posted by Quality88

For you maybe... Petty put on a good show. He wasn't at his best obviously, but it was still good.

if hes not in his prime, dont wanna see it.

[LSC9901]

I thought it was a good show for being live and not in a studio. The guy's 57 years old and still rockin'.

[Quality88]

Originally Posted by LSC9901

I thought it was a good show for being live and not in a studio. The guy's 57 years old and still rockin'.

Oh yeah.....

[bears9]

Tom Petty is from when I parents were my age, and I didn't think he was that bad. That counts for something