[Gotham Dark Knight]

Is it Brady,the team or a combo?

The 1972 Dolphins went part of their 17-0 season with a backup QB. Could the 2008 Patriots have done the same?

[Seahawker 562]

No i dont think they could of went 18-0 w/o brady. His throws are perfect, and hes good under pressure

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Seahawker 562

No i dont think they could of went 18-0 w/o brady. His throws are perfect, and hes good under pressure

Ihave not been impress with their backup either... I think at Brady gone down this year, we would be looking at an 11-5 team at best.

[LSC9901]

What if .... what if ??? We'll never know for sure but I think it is safe to say that an 18-0 record would have been difficult at best for any other combination.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by LSC9901

What if .... what if ??? We'll never know for sure but I think it is safe to say that an 18-0 record would have been difficult at best for any other combination.

I think on that team, Manning could have done it...possibly a Montana, a Steve Young...or maybe even a Roger Staubach.

[Seahawker 562]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

I think on that team, Manning could have done it...possibly a Montana, a Steve Young...or maybe even a Roger Staubach.

Yeah agreed. Young could deliver

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Seahawker 562

Yeah agreed. Young could deliver

I think no one mentions Young in the all time great QB debates...but he was a prolific passer with multiple passing titles...highly moblile...kept mistake to a minimum and very accurate.

[Lefty Noob]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

I think on that team, Manning could have done it...possibly a Montana, a Steve Young...or maybe even a Roger Staubach.

Johnny Unitas, without a doubt, could've gone 18-0 with them.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Lefty Noob

Johnny Unitas, without a doubt, could've gone 18-0 with them.

And do it in black high tops no doubt...

[Bette]

Why are we mostly looking at quarterbacks from the past? Dont you think any of them from today could? With those receivers and that O-line. Heck, even Grossman would have looked good. Not perfect, mind you, but good.
Romo, Favre, throw an interception and Defense will get the ball back.
Brady is good, very cool, very accurate, but he can be pressured and made a bit nervous if the opponents can get pass his O-line.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Bette

Why are we mostly looking at quarterbacks from the past? Dont you think any of them from today could? With those receivers and that O-line. Heck, even Grossman would have looked good. Not perfect, mind you, but good.
Romo, Favre, throw an interception and Defense will get the ball back.
Brady is good, very cool, very accurate, but he can be pressured and made a bit nervous if the opponents can get pass his O-line.

Grossman goes 11-5 at best...Romo 14-2 (he dates Simpson late in the season and loses focus) Favre 14-2...Manning possibly runs the table.

[Bette]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

Grossman goes 11-5 at best...Romo 14-2 (he dates Simpson late in the season and loses focus) Favre 14-2...Manning possibly runs the table.

Please dont tell me you mean your guy Eli here?

Of course, even he would have looked pretty good there. But not run the table.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Bette

Please dont tell me you mean your guy Eli here?

Of course, even he would have looked pretty good there. But not run the table.

No..big brother Peyton...Eli goes 12-4 maybe 13-3

[Lefty Noob]

Yeah, Peyton would too. Favre would roll the dice too many times and lose at least one. What about Carson Palmer, could he do it?

[azrael492]

What about McNabb? How would he do on this team. he is fairly accurate and doesn't get ruffled when he is pressured. He may get hurt during the season though