[Bette]

1. Tom Brady-Guy has 3 Super Bowl rings
2. Ben Roethlisberger-2 Super Bowls and an impressive list of 4th quarter comebacks
3. Peyton Mannning-you want him to be the guy who has his hands on the ball
4. Kurt Warner-only 1 Super Bowl win but played well even in his losses
5. Donovan McNabb-even with teams that werent super talented, he took them deep into the playoffs.

http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/blog/shutdown_corner/post/The-Shutdown-Five-Most-clutch-quarterbacks-in-t?urn=nfl,164119

What do you think of this list? Agree with any, disagree with any?

[simple simon]

in no order

Manning
Manning
Brady
Big Ben

its a little hard for me to think of a fifth right now .... i think i will go with Warner

[Bette]

Originally Posted by simple simon

in no order

Manning
Manning
Brady
Big Ben

its a little hard for me to think of a fifth right now .... i think i will go with Warner

You count Eli as a clutch quarterback? Wow, not one of my top 5 clutch quarterbacks.

[bears9]

Big Ben
Brady
Peyton Manning
Warner

That are my big four, I guess Eli would have to be five I can't really think of anyone else. Definately not McNabb, it's not Brees or Palmer they are stat guys. Yeah it would Eli

[mike honcho]

Big Ben
Warner
Payton Manning
Brady
Flacco

[Bette]

Originally Posted by mike honcho

Big Ben
Warner
Payton Manning
Brady
Flacco

Flacco is an interesting choice. Hasnt played as many games as the others, but for a young quarterback he took his team farther than you would expect with the talent he had around him.
Now Matt Ryan played well, but he had more talent to work with.
As far as Eli goes, this year will tell if he is the quarterback some think he is, or if he will fall to the wayside with out the likes of Burress and Toomer to help him out.

[simple simon]

funny how Romo isnt on anyones list

[Bleedin Purple]

Tarvaris Jackson!

Clutch when it comes to blowing games!

[Bette]

Originally Posted by simple simon

funny how Romo isnt on anyones list

Originally Posted by Bleedin Purple

Tarvaris Jackson!

Clutch when it comes to blowing games!

Looks like we are kind of in the same predicament BP
Except Romo isnt as bad, even simon cant think so.

[bears9]

What do mean Romo isn't clutch he threw that TD pass to put the home team ahead against the Steelers last year remember

[mike honcho]

Originally Posted by bears9

What do mean Romo isn't clutch he threw that TD pass to put the home team ahead against the Steelers last year remember

Getting lucky 1 time doesn't really make him a clutch qb.

[bears9]

Originally Posted by mike honcho

Getting lucky 1 time doesn't really make him a clutch qb.

What about that one time in the Playoffs were he messed up the field goal allowing the home team to win. Doesn't look that lucky now

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Bette

1. Tom Brady-Guy has 3 Super Bowl rings
2. Ben Roethlisberger-2 Super Bowls and an impressive list of 4th quarter comebacks
3. Peyton Mannning-you want him to be the guy who has his hands on the ball
4. Kurt Warner-only 1 Super Bowl win but played well even in his losses
5. Donovan McNabb-even with teams that werent super talented, he took them deep into the playoffs.

http://sports.yahoo.com/nfl/blog/shutdown_corner/post/The-Shutdown-Five-Most-clutch-quarterbacks-in-t?urn=nfl,164119

What do you think of this list? Agree with any, disagree with any?

McNabb???? Oh please...what has he done...ever???...even Eli's win over the Patsies has been bigger than anything McNabb has ever done in the NFL...

[Bette]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

McNabb???? Oh please...what has he done...ever???...even Eli's win over the Patsies has been bigger than anything McNabb has ever done in the NFL...

If I had a choice, I would take McNabb over Eli any day. No matter who McNabb has around him, he is dangerous.
Eli doesnt scare me unless he has a bevy of top notch talent around him. Then he might get lucky and hit the right target.
Think toughness, heart, and the ability to make plays with his legs. (ok,not so much today anymore) who comes to mind?

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Bette

If I had a choice, I would take McNabb over Eli any day. No matter who McNabb has around him, he is dangerous.
Eli doesnt scare me unless he has a bevy of top notch talent around him. Then he might get lucky and hit the right target.
Think toughness, heart, and the ability to make plays with his legs. (ok,not so much today anymore) who comes to mind?

Not McNabb, the man TO took to task for showing up out of shape for the Super Bowl...really now, if you are gonna throw Brady and his rings, and Big Ben and his (which he owes to the Defense) and then stick McNabb in there with the them...I gotta ask, what as he done? And how many Super Bowls has he visited without my man TO???