[Bette]

by Alex Marvel
Alex Marvez is a Senior NFL Writer for FOXSports.com. He's covered the NFL for 13 seasons as a beat writer and is the president of the Pro Football Writers of America. Here are 10 of his choices.

1. Miami RB Ronnie Brown
2. St. Louis QB Marc Bulger
3. Carolina QB Jake Delhomme
4. Denver QB Jay Cutler
5. New Orleans DE Charles Grant: Running back Deuce McAllister (knee) may seem like a stronger candidate from the Saints roster. But as indicated by the team's recent interest in free agent Shaun Alexander, there are no guarantees McAllister will be playing with New Orleans in 2008.
6. Houston RB Ahman Green
7. Tennessee DE Jevon Kearse
8. Pittsburgh RB Willie Parker
9. New York Giants TE Jeremy Shockey
10. Dallas LB Zach Thomas

FOX Sports on MSN - NFL -

These seem more like has beens than comebacks to me, but what do you think?

[simple simon]

Originally Posted by Bette

These seem more like has beens than comebacks to me, but what do you think?

seems way too early to decide either way on Jay Cutler imo

[Bette]

Originally Posted by simple simon

seems way too early to decide either way on Jay Cutler imo

I think its way too early to decide on any of them.
Actually on the Fox Poll, Jay Cutler was voted the most likely to comeback. I voted for Marc Bulger on there. Boy, was that a bad pick according to the rest of the voters.

[simple simon]

Originally Posted by Bette

Actually on the Fox Poll, Jay Cutler was voted the most likely to comeback.

come back from what exactly

the kid is only 25 ...... he had 20 TD's last year and 14 INT's and a passer rating of 88.1 ... not great numbers but he only has 3 years experience

i know this isnt your poll Bette .... but it seems odd to me ..... the kid has nothing to come back from .... he needs a couple more years to learn and a couple more good players to help him

[Bette]

Originally Posted by simple simon

come back from what exactly

the kid is only 25 ...... he had 20 TD's last year and 14 INT's and a passer rating of 88.1 ... not great numbers but he only has 3 years experience

i know this isnt your poll Bette .... but it seems odd to me ..... the kid has nothing to come back from .... he needs a couple more years to learn and a couple more good players to help him

His health issues simon. Take another look at the poll. They are all players who suffered from health issues. The writer of the poll wasnt thinking of players who just improved, he is talking about players who overcome their health problems. And with diabetes, Cutler has a stuggle ahead of him. I think there is a player on the Jets who has diabetes and has played for a few years but cant remember who.

I messed up the link and couldnt get it to work right. Dont know what I did wrong.

[simple simon]

Originally Posted by Bette

I messed up the link and couldnt get it to work right. Dont know what I did wrong.

what do you mean .... works fine for me

[Bette]

Originally Posted by simple simon

what do you mean .... works fine for me

ha ha got me . I couldnt figure out how that could be because I had tried earlier. Thanks

[simple simon]

well i vote for Everett ..... i hope he gets a coaching job and to me that would be the biggest comeback this season

[Dusty]

Cutler has to wear a special bracelet to monitor his blood sugar and keep an eye on it while he's playing quarterback in the NFL, talk about multi-tasking! I practically had Jay Cutler on a highway to Canton but while I hope he can manage this illness I don't think he can do that in the midst of a game and be effective. I really hope i'm wrong however.

[simple simon]

Originally Posted by Dusty

Cutler has to wear a special bracelet to monitor his blood sugar and keep an eye on it while he's playing quarterback in the NFL, talk about multi-tasking! I practically had Jay Cutler on a highway to Canton but while I hope he can manage this illness I don't think he can do that in the midst of a game and be effective. I really hope i'm wrong however.

im sorry but it doesnt impress me

Adam Morrison of the Bobcats has diabetes ..... the Bus played a Hall of Fame career with asthma

[Dusty]

Originally Posted by simple simon

im sorry but it doesnt impress me

Adam Morrison of the Bobcats has diabetes ..... the Bus played a Hall of Fame career with asthma

I hope you're right Simon. I think Cutler has tremendous ability and will be amazing to watch in the future. He makes the NFL better.

[Bette]

Originally Posted by simple simon

well i vote for Everett ..... i hope he gets a coaching job and to me that would be the biggest comeback this season

You cant vote for Everett. He's not on the list. Come on simon, follow the rules.

[simple simon]

Originally Posted by Bette

Come on simon, follow the rules.

Hello ..... im simple simon ...... have we met ?

[Bette]

Originally Posted by simple simon

Hello ..... im simple simon ...... have we met ?

Oh, that's right. You NEVER follow the rules. A law unto yourself.

[simple simon]

Originally Posted by Bette

Oh, that's right. You NEVER follow the rules. A law unto yourself.

so i see you have heard of me