[Geechee843]

simple question. RIGHT NOW who would you rather have on your team.

witha name like randy moss he should be driving a race car and "plaxico" should be a major producer/distributor of anti-depressants. but who would you rtather have?

we all know that randy has the speed advantage but we also know that plaxico has a better additude and plays all the time, not just "when he wants to".

toward the second half of the season moss started looking more like a one trick pony, run deep and catch while plaxico doesnt mind gettin dirty for it. throughout the playoffs randy was easily takne outta the game while plaxico showed rhonde barber,roy williams,terrance newman,AL HARRIS,and ellis hobbs who was boss. and those are the leagues premier db's. while randy seems kinda shy about goin over the middle. wat plax lacks in speed he more than makes up for in a chuck norris like additude. while randy moss can jump 97 feet into the air plax doesnt seem to mind pile driving a db just to catch a 7 yard slant. he plays with a mean streak, like a young micheal irvin.

so. who would you rather have?

[Quality88]

Plaxico.......

[simple simon]

Moss is the #1 WR in the game right now

[EmpireWF]

Can't go wrong with either.

[bears9]

Originally Posted by simple simon

Moss is the #1 WR in the game right now

Yep, completely agree.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by simple simon

Moss is the #1 WR in the game right now

Maybe. I think talent wise he is. But all around (including heart) top 5.

Still I take him over Plaxico.

[simple simon]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

Maybe. I think talent wise he is. But all around (including heart) top 5.

i can live with that

[Bette]

Moss got his tds easy. Plaxico had to fight for all of his, and with a bum ankle all season.
Short term, guess I would take Moss.
But if I was looking for a receiver that would hang in there thru good and bad, I would definitely have to take Plaxico.

[Phils20]

I would have to take Moss, if I had to give up TO!

[Quality88]

Originally Posted by simple simon

Moss is the #1 WR in the game right now

#1 without a ring ........
He is a good receiver. I would still take Plaxico.

[Geechee843]

moss wasnt very moss-ish in the playoffs. every decnt db he faced took nim out the game. plaxico OWNED EVERY db he faced. he made al harris look like he was on the practice squad

[Bette]

Originally Posted by Phils20

I would have to take Moss, if I had to give up TO!

I wouldnt give up TO for either of them. He fits in very well now.

[simple simon]

Originally Posted by Geechee843

plaxico OWNED EVERY db he faced.

ok, now you went and made me do this ..... remember, you brought this on yourself

Wild Card vs Tampa Bay ... 4 catches for 38 yards and 0 TDs

Divisional Round vs Dallas .... 1 catch for 5 yards and 0 TDs

NFC Championship Game vs Green Bay ... 11 catches for 151 yards and 0 TDs

Super Bowl vs New England .... 2 catches for 27 yards and 1 TD

doesnt look so impressive

[Phils20]

I'm truly shocked that this ins't a landslide for Moss. WOW. Is the dislike for him really poisoning the view by that much?

The talent level isn't even close.

I can't stand Moss, but I have to give credit where it is due!

[EmpireWF]

As far as Plaxico goes, he played the entire year with a completely bum ankle and leg. Just imagine how better he would have played if he was healthy. Hopefully we'll find out in 2008.

Plaxico came up big when it mattered most for the Giants. As did Moss.