[simple simon]

Here's the top 5 for Week 5

#1
McNabb

Four 300-yard passing performances in five games and only one INT for season. He made great pre-snap reads vs. Dallas defense and is doing great job of finding all his weapons.

#2
Grossman

Modest stats in blowout over Buffalo but made no mistakes, shows total command of offense and is spreading ball around to eight different receivers. He has over 100 QB rating for fourth time in five weeks.

#3
Rivers

He's playing with confidence far beyond his experience. Has great passing skills and handled the Steelers blitz to perfection while identifying one-on-one matchups.

#4
Damon Huard

For two weeks in a row he has shown pinpoint accuracy and an excellent command of the offense with two wins and over a 100 QB rating and clutch passing in the fourth quarter.

#5
Eli Manning

Manning finally put together a complete game in win over Washington with no interceptions. He wasn't sacked, had a 102.6 QB rating and an excellent vertical passing game.

ESPN.com - NFL - QB rankings: Week 5

so, there you have it

agree, disagree ?

[Gotham Dark Knight]

I dislike Grossman, but not as much as Huard...

And where are the Eli haters now?

[Lefty Noob]

Huard, eh? Interesting. Are we looking at the beginnings of a QB controversy in Kansas City, you think?