[Geechee843]

my big ten lovin uncle ironically thinks that dmac is da best between the two. of cours i disagree mainly cuz he's a big-ten fan but cuz i really do believe peterson is better. he's bigger,faster,more explosive, and people are actually scared to tackle em. plus when mcfadden gets to the pros he could be a bust, we already know wat peterson can do.

so my uncle says "well peterson gets hurt and dmac plays through injuries". but dmac gets hurt from gettin hit while peterson gets hurt from bull dozing people. basically dmac can only move the pile while peterson can break the pile.

wat yall think is betteer?

[vincesanity82]

Its hard to say cause Mcfadden hasnt played a year in the pros yet, but I believe Mcfadden will be better and accomplish more..

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Petterson is in his own league right now...but McFadden is probably more durable.

[Lefty Noob]

Originally Posted by vincesanity82

Its hard to say cause Mcfadden hasnt played a year in the pros yet, but I believe Mcfadden will be better and accomplish more..

That's the issue. If you compare their senior years, it's awful close. But with what AD's doing in the pros... man, McFadden's got some catching up to do.

[Geechee843]

haha yea he missed 2 games and is still the leagues leading rusher and jus might break ERIC DICKERSON"S single season rushing record

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Geechee843

haha yea he missed 2 games and is still the leagues leading rusher and jus might break ERIC DICKERSON"S single season rushing record

No, missing two games means he will miss the record...

[Geechee843]

i do nt know. wit that schedule he can easily have another 296 yard game(s)