[Tuck4Bama]

Let's start with a fairly obvious realization: Charlie Weis is a terrible college football coach.

Sure, he looked great the past two seasons when he was leading a pair of veteran-laden Notre Dame teams to consecutive BCS bowl berths. One day in the future, he may well do the same.

But when faced this season with the ultimate test of a college coach -- the universal challenge of molding a team full of talented but inexperienced players into a cohesive and successful squad -- Weis has failed miserably. It shouldn't be entirely surprising, after all, he had no prior training.

Weis' struggles prove problem with NFL-bred coaches

[Tuck4Bama]

Are their any opinions out there about NCAA to NFL or NFL to NCAA?

Spurrierr and Saban have shown the difficulties in the transitions from NCAA to NFL.

Now with Weis in the crosshairs of inability to develop talent at the collegee level tell me what you think?

[Lefty Noob]

Jimmy Johnson made the transition from pros to college pretty well. I think Bobby Ross did too. Not sure of anyone who went from a pro coordinators job to successful NCAA coach, but I'm sure someone has. Did Dennis Green take that path?