[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Tiny Tom

Dawson and Trammell aren't already in? I can't believe that! I say Big Mac, Gossage, Rice, Tommy John and right on the mason dixon line is Raines and Rijo.

Raines sure...but Rijo?...I mean I am a Reds fan and I would not consider Rijo

[Tiny Tom]

Well Rijo had a very good career and was a World Series hero so as I say on the Mason/Dixon line. Nowadays Rijo would be dominant I think but Raines should be in. Both guys are arguable however. Dawson and Trammell should have been in long ago!

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Tiny Tom

Well Rijo had a very good career and was a World Series hero so as I say on the Mason/Dixon line. Nowadays Rijo would be dominant I think but Raines should be in. Both guys are arguable however. Dawson and Trammell should have been in long ago!

I would argue that at the peak of his greatness that Dawson was over shadowed by both Dale Murphy and Jim Rice...Trammell's numbers are a bit better than some Hall of Famers but he has never gotten close to getting 20% of the votes needed...so I doubt he will make it.