[Gotham Dark Knight]

Who would you have on a composite All-Time great Baseball Fantasy Team (players in their prime of course)?

I think front runner would have to be Ty Cobb (AVG, Runs, RBI, and Mega steals...all but HRs), Sandy Koufax (W, ERA, K's and Whip),

Mays (his steal count was low by todays standards but he would produce in all categories), Ruth, Foxx, , Williams would all be bying for an OF spot...

"Rajah" Hornsby would have to go high at second...

[simple simon]

Ricky Henderson ?

[simple simon]

Ted Williams for average

[simple simon]

Mariano Rivera in his prime as a reliever

how about Eckersly ?

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by simple simon

Mariano Rivera in his prime as a reliever

how about Eckersly ?

Eck would have a very low whip, and help in saves, ERA and K's...

[simple simon]

Pedro from 97-05

his ERA was below 2.50 and he averaged 244 K's per season

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by simple simon

Pedro from 97-05

his ERA was below 2.50 and he averaged 244 K's per season

Yep...low Whip too...

[MJHMarc]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

Who would you have on a composite All-Time great Baseball Fantasy Team (players in their prime of course)?

I think front runner would have to be Ty Cobb (AVG, Runs, RBI, and Mega steals...all but HRs), Sandy Koufax (W, ERA, K's and Whip),

Mays (his steal count was low by todays standards but he would produce in all categories), Ruth, Foxx, , Williams would all be bying for an OF spot...

"Rajah" Hornsby would have to go high at second...

You can't have Sandy Koufax and Ty Cobb on the same team.

[simple simon]

Originally Posted by MJHMarc

You can't have Sandy Koufax and Ty Cobb on the same team.

why not ?

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by MJHMarc

You can't have Sandy Koufax and Ty Cobb on the same team.

It's a Fantasy team I can have freakin Terrell Owens pitching if I so desire...

[azrael492]

I would have Johnny Bench as my catcher.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by azrael492

I would have Johnny Bench as my catcher.

Monster power, decent average...stole on occassion...

[MJHMarc]

Originally Posted by simple simon

why not ?

Think about it.

[MJHMarc]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

Monster power, decent average...stole on occassion...

Mike Piazza is better, in my opinion.

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by MJHMarc

Mike Piazza is better, in my opinion.

Not as much power, but higher average...probably would come down to what your team is lacking more in average or power...