[vincesanity82]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

solid is not great...solid is solid ...Steve DeBerg was solid...no one calls him great...I think McNair fell short of what I expect from him...that's all I am saying.

Steve DeBerg? dude threw more career interceptions than touchdowns and has a QB rating of 74.2. He never won any mvp's or went to pro bowls either. Thats not solid my man..To me, Mcnair was a great QB..

[Bette]

Originally Posted by vincesanity82

Steve DeBerg? dude threw more career interceptions than touchdowns and has a QB rating of 74.2. He never won any mvp's or went to pro bowls either. Thats not solid my man..To me, Mcnair was a great QB..

Not sure I'll say that. Better than solid, but not great. Maybe pretty darn good.

Originally Posted by theduck

A superbowl ring.

I know one will ever agree with me on this but that ring is overrated.

[Lefty Noob]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

solid is not great...solid is solid ...Steve DeBerg was solid...no one calls him great...I think McNair fell short of what I expect from him...that's all I am saying.

DeBerg's QB rating is much lower than McNair's, though he did throw for 3,000 more yards in his career. The big difference between the two though, I think, is that DeBerg was a journeyman who never spent more than 65 games with each of his 7 teams. Yet, he does rank in the top 20 all-time for attempts, completions, and yards passing. It's an interesting comparison, to say the least.

[azrael492]

So, how does he stack up for the HOF? Does he get in? I don't thnk he qualifies.