[cjschev]

I think Marcus Giles is better. But, Kelly Johnson is definetly filling the void for Giles. He is young, and he is talented, but Marcus was a seasoned veteran who meshed well with the team. So, who is better, Kelly, or Marcus?

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by cjschev

I think Marcus Giles is better. But, Kelly Johnson is definetly filling the void for Giles. He is young, and he is talented, but Marcus was a seasoned veteran who meshed well with the team. So, who is better, Kelly, or Marcus?

From the looks of it...people are not sold on Johnson yet...he has not been picked up in my fantasy league.

[vincesanity82]

I hated to see marcus go...but, kelly johnson is doing awesome and in my opinion much better than giles, offensively better and def is about the same which is real good...if he hasnt been picked up in fantasy, unless your set @2b I would pick him up...

[Gotham Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by vincesanity82

I hated to see marcus go...but, kelly johnson is doing awesome and in my opinion much better than giles, offensively better and def is about the same which is real good...if he hasnt been picked up in fantasy, unless your set @2b I would pick him up...

Utley...need I say more...

[vincesanity82]

Originally Posted by Gotham Dark Knight

Utley...need I say more...

theres really not a huge difference between the 2

johnson- 5 hr 15 rbi 26 runs
utley- 5 hr 24 rbi 21 runs